Pakistani Bloggers
Showing posts with label Karachi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Karachi. Show all posts

May 1, 2020

Easy as ABC


I recently had a profound learning experience that I would like to share with you. It filled me with a lot of guilt and saddened me no end. On the other hand, it taught me a lot about myself.
I was driving somewhere one day. On the way, I saw a crowd of people gathered around a smashed-up car, the typical picture of an accident in our city. Being an emergency physician, I pulled my car over to the side and ran over to help. There was a woman on the tarmac, apparently unconscious in a pool of what looked like blood. I yelled at the police and the crowd to give me space. No one really heard me so I wormed my way over to her. To my relief, she was awake but a bit groggy. My medical training kicked in. ‘Airway (and neck), breathing , circulation’, the ABCs of resuscitating a sick person. I stabilized her neck with my hands to protect that part of her spine. This is vital because the cervical spine connects the brain to the rest of the body and controls virtually everything from breathing to movement. A tear in this delicate and exposed area of the human body and one can become paralyzed for life at best and dead at worst. I then looked at her chest and was relieved to see both sides of her chest rising regularly and equally. That meant her breathing was alright. Next, I needed to check her pulse. That would mean removing my hand from her neck, something I wanted to avoid. Luckily, the fact that she was awake and breathing significantly reduced the chances of her heart not beating so I put that off. I then yelled for a recount of events leading to the accident. Multiple people began to simultaneously recount their versions of the event. I cannot go into the exact details (due to privacy reasons) but suffice it to say that she had met with an accident after some disturbing events in her life. I then made a glaring error. I removed my hands from her neck to check her pulse (which I felt immediately quite strongly).
Nothing dramatic happened. Her neck did not snap, she did not become paralyzed and she continued breathing as before when everyone propped her up. That is besides the point. As a trained emergency physician, I HAVE to follow the ABCs mentioned above. I cannot just leave her neck based on a garbled history. I saw a smashed-up car (which indicates a high velocity accident) and a groggy woman. Ordinarily in a hospital setting, that is more than enough for me to secure her neck. Over here on the road I needed to follow my training. Perhaps, me being out of my comfort zone made me forget. Perhaps the fact that everyone else had moved her around without any obvious medical consequences lulled me into a false sense of security regarding the state of her neck. However, that is no excuse. As an emergency physician, it is my job to keep calm under pressure. If something had happened, it would be my fault alone. It costs nothing to stabilize her neck. Yet, the possible consequences of letting her neck go are devastating.
To decide if a neck can be let go, one can choose one of two famous algorithms- the NEXUS criteria and the Canadian C-spine rule. The former is simpler to follow and more relaxed about the neck as compared to the latter. The Canadian C-spine rule is marginally better but it is not unreasonable to depend on the NEXUS criteria alone. The NEXUS criteria allows you to relax about the neck if all of the following 5 criteria are met:
1)      The person is awake, alert and oriented to time, place and person,
2)      There is no evidence of intoxication,
3)      There is no focal neurologic deficit (i.e. no paralysis, loss of sensation anywhere among other things),
4)      No pain when pressing midline at the back of the neck, and
5)      No distracting injuries (simply put, a bleeding wound with say, the bone sticking out in the leg is bound to distract the victim from any pain in the neck)
With her, I could only reliably say that she met condition 1. I couldn’t confirm that she wasn’t intoxicated, given the bizarre circumstances of her accident and the fact that although she was oriented to time, place and person, she still wasn’t replying to all my questions consistently (likely due to the pain, but again, it costs nothing to keep her neck stable). She told me she couldn’t move her leg due to the pain. I also couldn’t do a proper examination to reassure myself regarding conditions 3, 4 and 5. Therefore, even by the relatively lenient NEXUS criteria, I should not have moved my hands from her neck till I could evaluate her properly or get a CT scan of her neck. Hence, the guilt.
Why the sadness though? As an ER physician, my daily bread and butter is this city’s dark underbelly. Consequences of its poverty, illiteracy, violence and mental strife are just another day in the ER. Therefore, quite naturally, I have developed a high level of immunity (and cynicism) to what most people would quail at. Whether that is good or bad is beside the point. It is necessary for me to remain detached so that I can function effectively as a doctor. Yet, seeing the very same thing I see everyday in the ER in a non-ER setting jolted my humanity awake and reminded me that the ‘guy on bed number so-and-so’ is not just another guinea pig that the conveyor belt-like triage has sent my way. Here was a woman with a horrible backstory (from what I gathered. Again, cannot go into details). Whatever the complete truth was, the end result was a devastated, injured woman with a mountain of problems. An uphill battle if ever I saw one.
What saddened me was how the police dealt with the case. I will not comment on the legal, administrative and police side of things (as it is not my place to do so), but I can give my two cents on how they handled the medical side of things. It is imperative that the police have some basic first aid training, enough so that they do no harm. Moving an accident victim about without any know-how of protecting the neck is criminal. They need to have SOPs in place that deal with this. They won’t always have a doctor at hand to help them out. While they all meant well and were most obliging to me, their lack of first aid knowledge proved a hindrance. Too much time was spent deciding whether they should keep the door of the car open to let her have some fresh air and constantly asking me if they could give her some water, despite my clear instructions regarding this. They also refused to send her to the hospital immediately. The reason they gave me was that she was wearing gold and if they took her immediately and the gold went missing along the way, they would be in hot water. Additionally, there were other logistical barriers that I cannot comment on. I later asked them that if she had looked like she was going to die any second, would they have reacted the same way? They vehemently insisted that they would have sent her to the hospital immediately. That is what bothers me. These medical decisions should not be in their hands. I understand that our emergency services leave a lot to be desired but in such circumstances, one would think the best option would be to get victims at the earliest to where they can be helped.
What did I learn about myself? I am not as authoritative as I should be. I have emergency training from arguably the best hospital in the country. I know exactly how to proceed in such situations. I must have confidence in myself and my abilities. There is a lot of research that backs everything that I do in such situations. I should learn to trust it, especially in such situations where I am the only advocate for my patient.

April 18, 2016

Strike while the Iron's Hot



I wrote this after Dr. Shakil Auj’s murder but forgot to post it:
My wife is a student at Karachi University. What follows is a synopsis of our discussion after teachers there went on strike due to Dr. Shakil Auj's murder (May Allah SWT grant him a place in the highest level of Paradise). We were wondering when strikes are morally okay (as in this case, the students suffered for no sin of their's) and when they are effective (Was the desired end achieved?). I shall discuss the latter only.
A few words about what follows: a) For the sake of simplicity, I shall refer to those on strike as strikers (in this case, the teachers) and those the strike is against as the strikees (in this case, the government/KU administration) and b) My discussion seeks to prove the following 2 statements:
1.       A strike is only effective when the service/product that is being removed by the strikers has value
2.       The strikers can only be defeated when the strikees remove a service/product that the strikers find of greater value than their own removed service/product.
Confused? Let's look at an example.
From 1974-75, British coal miners' union (National Union of Mineworkers) went on strike. The service being pulled in this case was coal, an essential requirement for the British populace, given oil's rising price after the 1973 crisis. Mines were shut down and coal production came to a virtual standstill. The British government instituted a 3 day work week with smaller working hours for the general public to reduce coal consumption to contest the strike. They failed and the government toppled.
From the above example, we see that the strikes are essentially a test of stamina and the ability to outlive the strikee. Both parties, the striker and strikee have reserves. The strikers have reserves of salaries which they get via subscriptions from their members so that they can pay the strikers when they are on strike. The government has reserves of coal. So in the end, the side that wins is the one whose reserves last longer. In 1974, the workers won. In 1984, the government did. The object of value was coal, something the population could not do without, leading to the government losing elections. But let's say the workers' reserves finished. Why couldn't the strike continue? Because no matter what principles one stands for, they all go down the drain when you're looking at starvation or a change in lifestyle, especially for those who depend on you. And those workers weren't exactly of the 1%. In 1984, the same NUM lost because the strikes outlasted the strikers, and the service removed was their salaries, something the strikers needed more than the government needed coal.
Often, our countrymen plunge headlong into strikes without properly calculating the practical consequences of their efforts. Let's look at political protests. When protesting, what product/service of value are they pulling? I can think of 2: the physical problems such as traffic caused by the protest and media coverage making the government look bad in the eyes of the international community. Both of these 2 types of value-pulling have not worked in the past because it doesn't really affect our government. It has very little bearing on the outcome of the next elections and 'the man' has no qualms about blocking roads for VIP movement anyway. Also, media coverage is too intangible an object of value. Will the media have the far-reaching effects strikers intend it to or does it just look good on paper?
Some political parties understood this and created what I term to be secondary services/products of value, i.e. when you have nothing of value, you create it. An example of secondary value is violence. Arming a political party to spread fear and using it as leverage creates value. People listen to them because they fear for their lives.
Now let's look at what value a student at a university has for the administration. What leverage can they garner when fighting for their rights? Unless said student is exceptional, none. Unless they can get the university grants through some brilliant ideas of theirs, the only object of value they have would be their fees. This works if the university is new and they need all the money they can get. But KU's fees are a joke and since it's an old established, economically feasible university, they won't ever be lacking for applicants. The only value that remains is that these students are future recruiters. They will go on to become leaders in their fields, putting their alma maters in a good light. However, this is too abstract and dicey a product of value. Besides, by the time these students go on to do great things, administrations would likely have changed by then, leaving the current administration no incentive to keep their students. Understanding this, many students form parties/unions or join political parties in school. This also explains campus violence.
Next I'll talk about civil disobedience movements. Keeping the above paradigm in mind, I believe civil disobedience will not work in today's world. Gandhi lived in a different world from ours. His India was a rural India, i.e. relatively self sufficient. Aside from modes of transportation and irrigation systems, what did the British do for India that would make the locals dependent on Britain? On the other hand, Britain needed fertile India's resources. Gandhi understood this and knew civil disobedience would hurt Her Majesty's coffers more than India's. The British government did not have a product/service of value that they could pull to hurt the largely independent Indian man without jeopardizing their own operation in India.
Fast forward to today. Urbanization dominates the country. We are miles deep in debt to the world. Globalization means we require Western products/services. Another intangible yet significant product of value is Western culture. Remember, there is only one Jessica Alba but many countries from where you can import cotton. Suddenly, the dynamics have changed. Taking to the streets to protest foreign interference in our country won't help much because frankly, my dear, we need 'em more than they need us.
I think that if we keep these few principles in mind, we as a nation can become wiser to when it's practical to go on strike and when it's just an ill-thought emotional response to injustice. Don't always strike while the iron is hot, or you may end up striking out.

August 23, 2011

Fear and Loathing in Karachi

I've been meaning to write this for quite a long time, but something or the other, mostly laziness, has kept me from doing so. But events in Karachi over the past few days have spurred me to pen my thoughts. Yesterday, I was coming home from my grandmother's with my parents when my mother piped up, 'Faysal beta, please be careful these days when you go visit your friends (as it's the end of summer, many friends are going back to college abroad, so I've been going around town bidding them adieu). I'm not forbidding you to leave the house, but try to meet them at their homes instead of at restaurants on the street, as 'they're' picking boys up at random who are never heard from again. Just the other day, your uncle was telling me how one of his workers' son was grabbed from the street along with his friends. Alhamdulillah, he escaped but the others weren't as lucky.' Now normally, my mum is quite chill for a mum. I've seen some pretty uptight mums so I'd say mine is the Ferris Bueller of them all. Dad takes our only car to work, so she lets me hop on public buses to go wherever I want (Once you get over the paan spitting, bad BO and filthy seats, it's not that bad really). Sure, she adds her fine print (which mum doesn't?); no bus after dark, Hassan Square is as far as you can go, and not on days when there's trouble in the city (since this is Karachi we're talking about, rule no. 3 keeps me grounded a lot of the time. That and my mum's refusal to let me go abroad for college makes me suspect she has empty nest syndrome (Read: She loves me so much. Awwww). Keeping in mind the mother I've just described, you can understand that I was quite surprised when she put a leash (albeit a thin one) on my city-trotting. At the time I just put it on maternal instinct, but later this incident got me thinking about what's been brewing in this fair city of ours. Let's be clinical about this. Let's put ourselves in the kidnappers' shoes for a bit. Either the kidnappers are serial killers, paedophiles or human traffickers or they have the sole nefarious purpose of instilling terror in the stout hearts of Karachiites for whatever sinister agenda(s). Whatever the cause, it's turned Karachi into a nervous, quaking wreck. And when people get nervous, they start acting irrationally. It is this irrationality that I shall discuss in this article. A quick google search shows that in 4 days 77 people have been killed in the recent spate of violence gripping our fair city. Another search shows that Karachi's population is approximately 13 to 15 million. Let us assume it is 13 mill. Therefore: 77/(4*13000000) = 0.0000015 That means that there are around 1.5 killings for every million people alive per day.1 million is the estimated population of Gulshan-e-Iqbal, a sprawling area. Everyday, max 2 people will get killed here. Out of a million. Factor in the fact that the violence is mainly limited to certain areas of the city only, and the probability decreases even further. There were 6 kidnappings on Tariq Road you say? Sweetie, have you SEEN the sheer number of people in that commercial centre at any given point in time? That means a BIG denominator, while the numerator remains 6. Low probability again. Which puts the problem in perspective doesn't it? In comparison, Tuberculosis is the 3rd biggest killer in Karachi’s slums, well above homicide. Hence, we have more reason to fear germs than terrorists. But I don't see us walking down the street wearing facemasks. Why? Is it because in our minds, bacteria are microscopic, virtually non-existent critters while a terrorist is a gun-toting, big, bad wolf in dire need of a shave? We really haven't changed from when we were kids. We still fall for the 'Bogeyman-will-come-and-eat-you-if you-don't-finish-your-greens' story our grandmothers told us in our childhoods. Now the lion is the terrorist and eating your greens is milling like scared bleating sheep.
  When our relatives and friends abroad or even in other Pakistani cities telephone in panic, saying they just saw that 6 more people died in Karachi and are we OK, don't we laugh it off, telling them not to worry? Where's that composure now? What's interesting is that people in the States think that we have a pig of a time here, that we literally dodge bullets everyday in our efforts to lead normal lives. But we know it's not as bad as they purport. We probably think the same of people in Iraq and Palestine. But ask them what it's like eking out an existence there (I have), and unless they live bang in the centre of a warzone, they'll roll their eyes too. The media plays a big part in this mass hysteria. In order to sell their brand, they only report that which is likely to shock and awe. Telling us how many people did NOT die in Karachi today is bad business for them. If they did that, the news would take a lot longer to deliver. Most of us would switch to the shopping channel. Remember, fear is a powerful tool to keep the masses in line. We won't speak up if we are scared. And that's what 'they' want. Case in point: we still refer to 'them' as 'them'. Can we get more Orwellian than this? To quote Roosevelt, the only thing we have to fear is fear itself. So put on a fresh pair of pants and be empirical about everything. There is comfort in probabilities.
 
Copyright © 2010 Faysy's blog. All rights reserved.
Blogger Template by